Conjectural history is a type of historiography isolated in the 1790s by dugald stewart, who termed it theoretical or conjectural history, as prevalent in the historians and early social scientists of the scottish enlightenment. He became one of the most influential academics in the eighteenth and. Selected philosophical writings emanuele levi mortera dugald stewart was appointed assistant professor of mathematics in the university of edinburgh in 1772, aged only 19. Dugald stewart synonyms, dugald stewart pronunciation, dugald stewart translation, english dictionary definition of dugald stewart. The collected works of dugald stewartvolume 1preface. Of this sort of conjectural or theoretical history. In most cases, it is of more importance to ascertain the progress that is most simple, than the progress that is most agreeable to fact account, p. He is best known for popularizing the scottish enlightenment, for his lectures at the university of edinburgh were widely disseminated by his many influential students.
Page 251 the proper distinction in the use of these particles, is elegantly marked in a passage of dr. Lectures and letters of dugald stewart 17531828 archives hub. In 1775 he took over his fathers chair and 10 years later was appointed professor of. Full text of the works of dugald stewart see other formats. The term conjectural history was coined by dugald stewart to describe this method of procedure11. It was the age of david hume, thomas reid and adam smith, of adam. Pdf hume, conjectural history, and the uniformity of. Books by peter gay the erilightenment portwood history. The pride and ornament of scotland by gordon macintyre isbn. Because humes position does not conform in any simple sense to dugald stewart s incontrovertible logical maxim that the capacities of the human mind have been the same in all ages, stewart s account of the method of conjectural history is, in any simple sense, inadequate as a description of humes practice. Of this sort of conjectural or theoretical history, the most unexceptionable specimens which have yet appeared. Download and read online for free the theory of moral sentiments. Prefacing adam smiths writings, stewart considered that some of his works belonged to a particular sort of inquiry entirely of modern origin stewart 1795. Full text of the works of dugald stewart internet archive.
Yet it is hard to see why, in his view, conjectural histories are not merely confabulated justso stories. Dugald stewart along with conjectural history to refer to a historical approach that starts from how things are in the present and from there imagines how they might have come to be such. The nature of conjectural history conjectural history was, it seems, first distinguished from the more conventional narrative form of history by dugald stewart. Jan 01, 2006 dugald stewart called these works theoretical or conjectural 34 histories because they offered hypotheses that would be in accord with and help explain the historical record, just as a history of physics or mathematics offers hypotheses that seek to be in accord with and help explain observable phenomena in the natural world. Stewart meant that smith used informed conjecture to fill the unavoidable gaps in the historical evidence, though hostile commentators have interpreted it as saying.
It is dugald stewart who coined the term and identified the methods chief features in 1795, when conjectural history was already wellestablished among scottish authors. The works of william robertson history of scotland. Scottish common sense realism, also known as the scottish school of common sense, is a realist school of philosophy that originated in the ideas of scottish philosophers thomas reid, adam ferguson, james beattie, and dugald stewart during the 18thcentury scottish enlightenment. Dugald stewart called these works theoretical or conjectural 34 histories because they offered hypotheses that would be in accord with and help explain the historical record, just as a history of physics or mathematics offers hypotheses that seek to be in accord with and help explain observable phenomena in the natural world.
Dugald stewart s most popular book is elements of the philosophy of the human mind, volume 1. The purpose of this paper is to examine smiths four stages theory of history as an account of economic and social development, with an emphasis on the arguments and evidence he used to support it. Best sellers gift ideas new releases whole foods todays deals amazonbasics. This history, first practiced by montesquieu, later explored by scottish, sociologists like adam ferguson, and finally christened theoretical or conjectural history, was sociology. Gleanings from dugald stewarts works, with additions. Sep 22, 2015 the collected works of dugald stewart volume 1. Dugald stewart definition of dugald stewart by the free. In examining the history of mankind, as well as in examining the phenomena of the natural world, stewart wrote in his life of adam smith, when we cannot trace the process by which an eventhas been produced, it is often of importance to be able to. Identifying the methodological achievement of scottish enlightenment historians and philosophers in a retrospective assessment of the life and writings of adam smith delivered to the royal society of edinburgh rse in 1793, dugald stewart coined what would become a famous phrase. Dugald stewart frse frs was a scottish philosopher and mathematician. One is to attempt to base on general considerations, on what dugald stewart calls known principles of human nature, conjectures as to first beginningsof political society hobbes, of.
Dugald stewart was appointed assistant professor of mathematics in the university of edinburgh in 1772, aged only 19. He became one of the most influential academics in the eighteenth and nineteenthcentury european republic of letters. Dugald stewart stewart, dugald, 17531828 the online. The values and ideas of the scottish enlightenment were carried south of the border by the former students of dugald stewart. The scottish enlightenment the history of economic. Dugald stewart author of elements of the philosophy of the. Introduction, forum for modern language studies 10. He was educated at the citys royal high school where he became interested in the classics, and in session 17651766 entered edinburgh university attending greek, logic, and natural. Pdf hume, conjectural history, and the uniformity of human. Human nature the science of man david hume the unity of the sciences dugald stewart the theory of ideas david hume mind and its operations thomas reid pt. Featured texts all books all texts latest this just in smithsonian libraries fedlink us genealogy lincoln collection. Pbut whatever history the enlightenment historians pursued, they focused their attention 011 the rise and decline of the philosophic party, on the fortunes of. Hume and conjectural history journal of scottish philosophy.
Ethics morality and the moral sense francis hutcheson morality and benevolence david hume sympathy, propriety and merit adam smith on the proper estimate. Conjectural history is the probabilistic description of the prehistory of human institutions such as language or property, in the. Yet it is hard to see why, in his view, conjectural histories are not. Reid emphasized mans innate ability to perceive common ideas and that this process is inherent in and interdependent. When one of the old scottish kings was making an inquiry into the tenure by which his nobles held their lands, they started up, and drew their swords. Conjectural history in his biographical account of smiths life, his friend dugald stewart described smiths method as conjectural history, initiating a debate about the methodological basis of smiths history which has continued ever since. The scottish enlightenment is one of the great achievements of european culture. As stewart saw it, such history makes space for speculation about causes of events, by postulating natural causes. To the modern reader this might appear a rather large if, but the projectof the sketches is of a piece with a widespread commitment on the part of eighteenthcentury scots to what dugald stewart called theoretical or. As stewart saw it, such history makes space for speculation about causes of events, by postulating natural causes that could have had such an effect. Dugald stewart formulates the principle underlying conjectural history.
But mills use of conjectural history was more explicitly radical than any of his scottish forebears, including millar, whose opinions had. Conjectural history is the probabilistic description of the prehistory of human institutions. Scottish philosophy in 18th century scotland in the. If for dugald stewart francis hutcheson was a scottish philosopher, moore brings out hutchesons irish dimension, describing a. Dugald stewart, on conjectural history essays on philosophical subjects further reading part 3.
Dugald stewart claims that conjectural history is the peculiar glory of the latter half of the eighteenth century. Dugald stewart on conjectural history and human nature. Jul 01, 2010 edited and introduced by alexander broadie. Search the history of over 424 billion web pages on the internet. Simon evnine, hume, conjectural history, and the uniformity. Dugald stewart, philosopher and major exponent of the scottish common sense school of philosophy. Books by peter gay the erilightenment portwood history class. Dugald stewart was born in edinburgh on 22 november 1753. I will briefly distinguish the meaning of humes natural history from civil, ecclesiastical, universal, and popular histories, as well as from other kinds of natural history and from the genre invented later by dugald stewart but with reference to humes book of conjectural history. The method of conjectural history is used in a number of different ways.
Dugald stewart has 143 books on goodreads with 141 ratings. Towards the end of the enlightenment, dugald stewart dubbed this kind of investigation into social development theoretical or conjectural history, because it tried to fill in gaps in historical knowledge about particular nations by means of conjectures based on empirical knowledge of other nations that were thought to be at the same. In his biographical account of smiths life, his friend dugald stewart described smiths method as conjectural history, initiating a debate which has continued ever since. The collected works of dugald stewart volume 1 by dugald stewart preface. Hester chapone, letters on the improvement of the mind 10. In philosophy, law, economics, politics, linguistics and the physical sciences, scots were key players in changing the way the world was viewed. Because humes position does not conform in any simple sense to dugald stewarts incontrovertible logical maxim that the capacities of the human mind have been the same in all ages, stewarts account of the method of conjectural history is, in any simple sense, inadequate as a description of humes practice. This paper examines stewart s views about the epistemic and moral value of conjectural history.
In this book he set out to establish the precise position occupied by the hindus in the scale of civilisation by means of a potent combination of benthamite norms, classical political economy and the techniques of conjectural history perfected by scottish philosophers and historians. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. He was the son of matthew stewart 17151785, professor of mathematics at edinburgh university. He is best known for popularizing the scottish enlightenment and his lectures at the university of edinburgh were widely disseminated by his many influential students. Educated at the university of edinburgh, where his father was professor of mathematics, stewart began teaching there when he was 19. This paper examines stewarts views about the epistemic and moral value of conjectural history. He remarked on its use in the writings of adam smith, but the sort of inquiry to which we find stewart referring is a method for understanding social phenomena which was. By these, said they, we acquired our lands, and with these we will defend them. In 1783 he was a joint founder of the royal society of edinburgh.
Redman history of political economy, volume 32, number 3, fall 2000, pp. Historical writing and moral psychology introduction 9. Dugald stewart scottish philosopher and follower of thomas reid stewart. Dugald stewart author of elements of the philosophy of. Hello select your address best sellers customer service new releases find a gift customer service new releases find a gift.
435 1242 858 403 1150 596 1089 512 752 837 899 86 680 1590 1294 759 928 330 56 1409 847 455 1200 923 966 333 767 357 1340 783